In Spin the Sky,
Stauber transforms the bones of the Odyssey into near space opera.Cesar Vaquero leaves home to fight in the
Spacer War, only to spend 15 years wandering before returning home.His wife Penelope is running the family ranch
and fending off suitors as best she can.Homer’s islands are now orbitals, each one stranger and potentially more
deadly than the last.
A couple of things really stand out.First, the character development is
excellent.While this book has a fairly
large cast of characters, they feel fleshed out and developed.Minor characters feel more enigmatic than underdeveloped.There’s a sense of mystery with them (Asia,
for example) where you’d love to see more of their own stories.Secondly, the universe of Spin the Sky is a fascinating
place.The orbitals are diverse and wondrous
places.Again, there’s a sense that
other fantastic tales of this universe could be told.
***minor spoilers***
My major gripe is that a couple of plot points seemed
forced, rather than to come naturally from the characters.Why exactly did Cesar have to travel for 15
years before he could return home?Why
did the black hats need the Vaqueros’ cattle?
I’m no classics scholar, but I had a lot of fun making the
connections between Cesar’s misadventures and those of brave Ulysses.
In the midst of the Dark Ages, seven strangers are forced to
work together to defend a village from an advancing army.Of course, since this is a DC comic, & a
supernatural one at that, the strangers are more than perhaps meets the
eye.We have a demon, a sorceress, an
amazon, an immortal, & several others who are more than normal humans.
Demon Knights
gives Cornell an opportunity to play with a variety of comic & fantasy
tropes.Our protagonists are more grey
hats than white hats, each working for his or her own motivation, which are not
necessarily for the greater good.The
villains of the piece do not have the same subtlety.They are pure black hats, willing to pillage
& kill for their own gain.
While not as grim or nihilistic as some modern age comics, Dark Knights does feature quite a bit
of graphic violence.Our Dark Age
protagonists do not have any Silver Age prohibitions about killing, & often
this is depicted in graphic ways.
If one goal of the “New 52” was to make DC’s titles more
accessible to new readers, then Demon
Knights has succeeded admirably.Cornell balances information and mystery well, giving enough information
to allow for characterization, yet allowing for questions yet to be
answered.Additionally, as a standalone
piece, this first volume works well as a complete story arc.
The story begins simply enough.A man attends the funeral of his reclusive
godfather.After the funeral, he meets a
beautiful mysterious woman named Jo.Jo
saves his life, and he finds himself enmeshed in a decades long conflict that
is clearly out of his league.
Brubaker uses flashbacks to tease out the backstory on Jo,
Hank (the godfather), and this conflict.Slowly as the story progresses, we discover that the noir story becomes
one of Lovecraftian horror instead.
Brubaker is widely acknowledged as a writer who is very
skilled in the tropes of noir.That all
comes to play here.The storyline is a
classic, on par with James M Cain et al.What is perhaps surprising is his deft touch at the horror
elements.While in this first
installment the horror tropes are secondary to the noir, he works the horrific
elements into the solid foundation of his everyday world.
Likewise Sean Phillips does an excellent job handling the
art duties.The preponderance of the
book look & feel appropriate for a hardboiled tale, yet he handles the
creepy Lovecraftian horrors protruding into this world easily.The contrast makes the emerging horrific
elements even more striking.
Since the overall story is as yet unfinished, it’s
impossible to fully judge the plotting or storytelling.However, this first installment is compelling
& leaves me eagerly awaiting the next volume.
Yesterday’s Hero
picks up where No Hero has left
off.After saving the Earth from the
Lovecraftian horrors of the first book, Arthur Wallace & the team from MI37
must now stop time travelers from the Soviet Union who are attempting to change
the time stream in order to achieve Soviet supremacy.
If you haven’t yet read No
Hero, that would be recommended before trying Yesterday’s Hero.Wood does
very little to bring new readers up to speed.I think that you would probably be a bit lost.
It’s impossible to evaluate series titles without reference
to the other books in the series.In
this case, I have to feel that Yesterday’s
Hero comes out rather poorly.While
there were some issues with character development in No Hero, I felt that it was rather excusable considering that it
was the first book in the series.Unfortunately, rather than delve more deeply into the characters already
introduced, Wood introduces more than a few new characters.The effect is that now we have a large number
of underdeveloped characters, rather than a deepening relationship with any of
the characters in the series.
Additionally, the change in focus on the villains of the
piece changed the tone considerably.While the Lovecraftian horrors of the first book provided a nice horror
element, the Soviets of Yesterday’s Hero
seemed rather toothless in comparison.In fact, the entire premise of the villains struck me as rather
hilarious.I found myself wishing that
Wood had played up the comical nature of this threat.
Still, many of the strengths of No Hero do carry over into this second
title.The pacing was first rate, with
action & intrigue propelling the reader through the story.The bureaucratic horrors of government work
are further explored, and Wood does still provide the wit that was so charming
in the No Hero.
I ran across a course syllabus for Cal Berkeley recently. It's an ethnomusicology class focusing on the music of Jack Rose. The syllabus is online [pdf]. Twelve weeks of listening to albums & then discussing? Where was this back when I needed credits?!
This is a fun romp through standard, if well used urban
fantasy tropes.Police detective Arthur
Wallace stumbles into a secret world of magic & Lovecraftian horror.He’s enlisted in the super-secret MI37, whose
mission is to protect our reality.While
all his fellow agents have special abilities or skills, he’s just a copper with
a job to do.
The pacing is excellent, with intrigue and action propelling
you along.There’s a generous dose of
humor used to cut the action and horror.
While utterly entertaining, I found myself wishing that
there was something a bit more original here.Tropes can be great fun, but when the roadmap is followed so closely, it
is a bit disappointing.
When superhero Steve Clarke (aka Reaver) is defeated by
Octagon & his band of evil henchmen, rather than killing him on the spot,
he is given two weeks to live.We follow
Steve as he attempts to complete his modest bucket list, which primarily consists
of unfinished business from his life before he became a superhero.
Clarke’s world is clearly post Miller & Moore.The heroes are burdened by their abilities
and the consequences of their actions.The villains are very very evil.There
are less wacky bank jobs and more burning schoolchildren alive.Clarke himself is a big dumb lug of a
hero.Thanks to the silver age origin
story, he goes from being a sexually repressed teenager to a beefy guy who hits
things.
The pacing and use of superhero tropes is excellent.Tobin’s use of flashbacks allows us to learn
about the history of the Reaver.His
encounters with other heroes and villains propel the story forward even as they
flesh out the world.
Somewhat problematic is Tobin’s treatment of women and
sexuality.Female characters are
consistently underdeveloped, and over sexualized.And while I have not done a head count, the
feeling is that more female characters are villainous than not.Some of this is attributable to the story
being told from Clarke’s POV.He is
after all, a superbro.Still, I would
have liked to see more three dimensional characterization of some female
characters (in particular Adele).
***slight spoiler***
The ending was wonderful.After wallowing in the grimgritty world of the Reaver, Tobin shows that
the answer is to uphold classic heroic values.Why?Because the world needs the
symbol of heroes, even if the reality does not truly match that symbol.Even if imperfect, I applaud the effort to
meld a realistic tone with the idealism of past generations.
Are you a fan of genre tropes?If so, this is a book that you will
love.It loves steampunk tropes even
more than you do.It wallows in them,
rejoicing as it shouts “yes, may I have another!”
An odd couple work for a secretive government agency.They are battling a variety of evil secret
organizations.Over the course of the
book we have dirigibles, mad scientists, assassins, robots (& robot
armies), orgies, duels, exotic weaponry, fantastical inventions, mysterious
libraries, street urchins, asylums, & more!
At this point you may be thinking that this sounds like the
most derivative thing you’ve ever heard of.It’s not.The reason is that
these tropes haven’t been used because of laziness.They all are used in afun knowing way (try to identify & count
the references to Victorian or SF literature).
It may not be the deepest novel you read this year, but by
Jove, it’s fun.
By now you should know what to expect from a Laundry
novel.Bob gets called in to investigate
a strange situation, it all goes horribly awry, & he finds himself
outnumbered and outgunned.And the fate
of the world is on the line.
This time around, Bob goes to America to look into an “Evangelical”
minister.One of those guys with a
megachurch & whathaveyou. He’s there
in a supervisory context, on loan to the Externals department(yeah, Bob hadn’t heard of those guys
either).As you can probably guess, the
minister is in fact trying to summon Lovecraftian horrors.And Bob & his “externals” have to stop
the threat.
If you haven’t read any earlier Laundry novels, this is NOT
the place to start.Stross doesn’t slow
down to explain the workings of the Laundry universe or the Laundry
itself.You will be confused &
lost.It’s better to read the series from
the beginning.
I was a bit disappointed that we didn’t spend much time with
some of the usual supporting characters, but very much enjoyed the introduction
of new characters.Hopefully they’ll be
back, perhaps even with some spinoff stories of their own.
Given that the villain of the piece is nominally an
Evangelical, I’m not surprised to see that there’s been a bit of a backlash to
the discussion of religion in the book.Whatever Stross’ personal beliefs, he seemed to deal with religion in a
way that is consistent with the rules of the Laundry universe.It is a dark, godless universe where the “One
True Religion” exists to summon back Eldrich horrors.If you have personal problems with this
Lovecraftian take on existence, then this probably isn’t the book for you.
This is a bit later than I had planned, but here are my ten favorites from the first half of 2012. In no particular order:
The Carolina Chocolate Drops Leaving Eden
The Chocolate Drops have been perhaps the most consistent of the new generation of string bands. Even after a lineup shuffle, they come forward with yet another collection of traditional but contemporary songs.
Todd Snider Time As We Know It: The Songs of Jerry Jeff Walker
Thestory is that Jerry Jeff was one of Todd's big inspirations for starting down his musical journey. I'd never given it much thought, but once the connection was pointed out, it seems obvious. This is a relaxed look at selected material from Walker's catalog. Snider avoids some of the obvious selections, opting instead for some deep cuts. It's a real tribute to both performers how true the performances feel to both Snider & Walker.
The Chieftains Voice of Ages
Generally, the "bring in a bunch of guests" theme is an indicator that the album is a dud. (There's too many of these to count, look them up yourself.) Voice of Ages is the rare example where this approach works. By focusing on young Americana artists, The Chieftains have invigorated their own sound. More importantly, the guests own music works well with what The Chieftains actually do. This is perhaps the biggest surprise of the year for me.
Dr John Locked Down
Unlike so many "legacy" artists, Dr John has continued to release vital music throughout his career. However, for whatever reasons -- lack of label push or unwillingness to pander to trends -- his more recent albums have been critically ignored. Locked Down has received the push from Nonesuch (a great label match for him, btw). He's been paired with Dan Auerbach from The Black Keys on production. Auerbach's retro sensibilities prove to be a great compliment to Dr John. He provides a warm organic feel to the production, matching the veteran New Orleans performer with a variety of A list retro-funk session players.
Chelle Rose The Ghost of Browder Holler
Chelle Rose seems to be the frontrunner in 2012's "Lucinda Williams" category. Part country, part rock.
Lucero Women & Work
The album cover should tip you off to the classic Southern rock style of this album. Lucero has become the most dependable of the modern Southern bands. (Yeah, Truckers fans, I said it.) While perhaps a step down from the quality of their last release, Women & Work delivers on its promises.
South Memphis String Band Old Times There
After releasing one of my favorites of 2011, the South Memphis String Band returns with another strong release. This time, they selected material to create a dialogue about race. Of course, this can be problematic for some, & may account for the resounding silence that met the release of this album.
The Wandering Go On Now, You Can't Stay Here
Luther Dickinson assembled an interracial female band (not as a backing band, he's more the guitar only guy, the ladies provide the focus). The project focuses on prewar blues and string band music.
Luther Dickinson Hambone's Meditation
This is Dickinson in full blown Fahey mode. Primitive blues, ragas, etc etc.... Probably for guitar geeks only, but I find it to be a beautiful instrumental piece.
The Wood Brothers Live volume 1: Sky High
This is the first live collection from this Medeski Martin & Wood spinoff project. It's a great collection showcasing their folky funky jazzy jammy tunes.